237094
i wld like to discuss this.
if someone votes 100% on a major, they get some additional playa points. but thats it...
one time reward, and then your big commitment is basically off the tabel again.
sure, you know how many hours you spent listening to all the entries, writing all the comments and tags, etc
but theres no way for others to know.
the hall of completionists in the lyceum shows the botbrs who submitted to every format. its easy to keep up to date because the data is public.
a similar "hall of voting completionists" would be so cool to have, but the major battle voting data isnt public.
i am not requesting major voting data to be public - but wldnt it be cool if after tally - and with a certain amount of entries in a battle (more than 100?), a new tab next to "Info & Rules" and "x Entries" and "Comments" shows up, that says "Voters", and it shows... either *only* those with a % of 100... or maybe the top list of everyone who voted at least ... 75%? maybe...?
im just dropping this idea here, because to me it wld be a big extra motivator to show up on a list, that you can check even years after the battle ended. and for those who participated i think its also cool to see who checks their stuff.
downsides cld be:
- people vote lazily only to show up on the list
-> lazy/troll voting is already happening sometimes and admins catch it and ail it. and people cld already feel motivated to vote lazily simply to get more points. a new page that just gives stats, instead of points, doesnt promote lazyvoting imo
- the people who vote on (almost) everything have a higher INF so their votes will have the bigger impact on results. if only one or two botbrs are on the list, people cld think that this small group alone is responsible for the outcome
-> i think this is a valid concern, but you can already tell by average amount of comments and favs by a botbr on a battle, who voted a lot. criticists often like to give feedback too ;) and most people share their 100% progress in chats anyway most of the time.
if someone votes 100% on a major, they get some additional playa points. but thats it...
one time reward, and then your big commitment is basically off the tabel again.
sure, you know how many hours you spent listening to all the entries, writing all the comments and tags, etc
but theres no way for others to know.
the hall of completionists in the lyceum shows the botbrs who submitted to every format. its easy to keep up to date because the data is public.
a similar "hall of voting completionists" would be so cool to have, but the major battle voting data isnt public.
i am not requesting major voting data to be public - but wldnt it be cool if after tally - and with a certain amount of entries in a battle (more than 100?), a new tab next to "Info & Rules" and "x Entries" and "Comments" shows up, that says "Voters", and it shows... either *only* those with a % of 100... or maybe the top list of everyone who voted at least ... 75%? maybe...?
im just dropping this idea here, because to me it wld be a big extra motivator to show up on a list, that you can check even years after the battle ended. and for those who participated i think its also cool to see who checks their stuff.
downsides cld be:
- people vote lazily only to show up on the list
-> lazy/troll voting is already happening sometimes and admins catch it and ail it. and people cld already feel motivated to vote lazily simply to get more points. a new page that just gives stats, instead of points, doesnt promote lazyvoting imo
- the people who vote on (almost) everything have a higher INF so their votes will have the bigger impact on results. if only one or two botbrs are on the list, people cld think that this small group alone is responsible for the outcome
-> i think this is a valid concern, but you can already tell by average amount of comments and favs by a botbr on a battle, who voted a lot. criticists often like to give feedback too ;) and most people share their 100% progress in chats anyway most of the time.
