82302
There are a few things I'd like to bring up regarding collaborative entries. I know puke you're busy with many things, but I think this should be a somewhat high priority for the site since the feature is already half implemented.
1. Favorite counter does not always display correctly on collaborative entries. http://battleofthebits.com/arena/Entry/Vertical+Asymptote/25312/ Notice how here there are 8 favs but the counter shows 7. A similar thing happened with gyms/ttj's Metal entry, but seems to have corrected itself at some point.
2. Medals and badge progress are not shared between collaborators. Easily the most important concern; no matter how many collaborators there are, how the effort is distributed, or how well the song does, ONLY THE SUBMITTER gets the medals and the badge progress, which is pretty darn unfair, especially if everyone put in equal effort to make the song happen. They still do get the reslutz points though, which should be even more reason to have the indication of where those points came from. This would have to be corrected for any past collabs as well, which might be a good incentive to fix the problem sooner than later.
3. In a similar vein as the last but less important, alerts are also not shared. I think in most cases all the collaborators will be equally interested in the status of their song, so it's only fair to indicate directly to them when there are new favs/comments/tags.
1. Favorite counter does not always display correctly on collaborative entries. http://battleofthebits.com/arena/Entry/Vertical+Asymptote/25312/ Notice how here there are 8 favs but the counter shows 7. A similar thing happened with gyms/ttj's Metal entry, but seems to have corrected itself at some point.
2. Medals and badge progress are not shared between collaborators. Easily the most important concern; no matter how many collaborators there are, how the effort is distributed, or how well the song does, ONLY THE SUBMITTER gets the medals and the badge progress, which is pretty darn unfair, especially if everyone put in equal effort to make the song happen. They still do get the reslutz points though, which should be even more reason to have the indication of where those points came from. This would have to be corrected for any past collabs as well, which might be a good incentive to fix the problem sooner than later.
3. In a similar vein as the last but less important, alerts are also not shared. I think in most cases all the collaborators will be equally interested in the status of their song, so it's only fair to indicate directly to them when there are new favs/comments/tags.
