154770
Is the selling of user songs on bandcamp not a violation of the "NonCommercial" part of the creative commons license we all agree to whenever we submit a song? I know the money is supposedly being given to charities, but at least one of these "charities" is on extremely shaky ground regarding its status as a charity (see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Lives_Matter_Global_Network_Foundation#501(c)(3)_transparency,_tax_concerns,_and_New_Impact_Partners_allegations ). Furthermore, we only have puke7's word that he is donating the money to charity, right? Even further still, people might have preferences about which charities they would want to support. Luckily, when you have money you can use it to support whichever charity you want. Your money, your choice. puke7 never asked us which charity to support. Because it's his money, right? That's commercial. He's selling our songs and then using the money (or not) on charities that he believes are a good cause. It's at his discretion. It's his money. If you run a business and donate some of your money to a charity that doesn't make you a charity. You are still engaging in commercial enterprise.
Even if botb were a charity, "uses by organizations, by individuals, or for charitable purposes are less commercial but not decidedly noncommercial." Source: https://wiki.creativecommons.org/wiki/Defining_Noncommercial#From_the_Executive_Summary
In summary, I believe selling our songs on bandcamp violates the NonCommercial license that we uploaded them under. Please either take the songs down off of bandcamp or stop charging money for them. At the very least ask people before you put them up. Thank you!
Even if botb were a charity, "uses by organizations, by individuals, or for charitable purposes are less commercial but not decidedly noncommercial." Source: https://wiki.creativecommons.org/wiki/Defining_Noncommercial#From_the_Executive_Summary
In summary, I believe selling our songs on bandcamp violates the NonCommercial license that we uploaded them under. Please either take the songs down off of bandcamp or stop charging money for them. At the very least ask people before you put them up. Thank you!