Help me categorize stuff ( ゚^゚)
BotB Academy Bulletins
 
 
75158
Level 26 Mixist
A-zu-ra
 
 
 
post #75158 :: 2016.12.17 1:11am :: edit 2016.12.25 7:07pm
  
  Dimeback and Baron Knoxburry liēkd this
Is this not-from-BotB piece of music considered a "wildchip" or not? What do you guys think?

This is a tri-daily thing that I'm thinking about doing (starting today) where I give a thing on the YouTubbs and ask y'all if the song I posted should be categorized as a "wildchip" song or a "not wildchip" song. Mostly doing this to pique my curiosity on what the concensus of this site thinks on what categories these songs fit in.

Latest song!
Helix Nebula / Anamanaguchi
(album ver.)
Helix Nebula / Anamanaguchi
(NSF only)
http://www.strawpoll.me/11956610

Past songs
Neko ni Kakomarete Kurashitai / YMCK

http://www.strawpoll.me/11935045

Something Mystical / Shinji Hosoe

http://www.strawpoll.me/11916936

(An excerpt of) 8-Bits of Christmas / Seth Everman

http://www.strawpoll.me/11893637
 
 
75159
Level 28 Chipist
gotoandplay
 
 
 
post #75159 :: 2016.12.17 1:13am :: edit 2016.12.17 1:21am
could you add the option to tick both
edit; thx :)
 
 
75216
Level 26 Mixist
Xaser
 
 
 
post #75216 :: 2016.12.18 6:43pm
  
  Jangler liēkd this
The question is "is it wildchip or not?" Checking both defeats the entire purpose.
 
 
75217
Level 23 Mixist
shinichi
 
 
 
post #75217 :: 2016.12.18 9:21pm
  
  MiDoRi, gotoandplay, Jimmyoshi and A-zu-ra liēkd this
imo the choices should then be "wildchip" and "not wildchip" because chiptune falls under the allgear radar as well
 
 
75218
Level 26 Mixist
A-zu-ra
 
 
 
post #75218 :: 2016.12.18 9:47pm
  
  Modus Ponens and shinichi liēkd this
I'll consider these for the next poll (Tuesday) :o
 
 
75236
Level 26 Mixist
A-zu-ra
 
 
 
post #75236 :: 2016.12.19 10:52pm
  
  shinichi liēkd this
 
 
75237
Level 22 Chipist
RazerBlue6
 
 
 
post #75237 :: 2016.12.19 11:36pm :: edit 2016.12.20 3:58am
  
  gotoandplay and A-zu-ra liēkd this
For the second one I'd day it begins as a wildchip piece, but after that feel sorta goes away, so I'd say it's not wildchip
 
 
75296
Level 26 Mixist
A-zu-ra
 
 
 
post #75296 :: 2016.12.22 10:00am
Third one! And of course, I just had to do YMCK.

Neko ni Kakomarete Kurashitai / YMCK

http://www.strawpoll.me/11935045
 
 
75301
Level 28 Chipist
gotoandplay
 
 
 
post #75301 :: 2016.12.22 11:02am :: edit 2016.12.22 11:11am
  
  shinichi, A-zu-ra and Jangler liēkd this
:o this song and video is tres cool (stomping cat 4eva).

It's made me notice something about my preferences for wildchip - since with the named formats its considered kinda 'out there' to try and make the sound almost completely other to the chip that it comes from, whereas with my wildchip preferences its almost the other way round, where you kind of want to notice that theres soundchip sounds (that is, where the user hasnt specified using a chip at all)

so for instance, a wildchip entry that is a bucket for a entry using a soundchip (like blueshift galaxy for example), is doesnt matter as such whether there are evident chip-like sounds or not since it can be trusted that the 2a03 and fds are capable of doing that. Its only if theres no known involvement of a soundchip that it seems to matter how obvious it is.
 
 
75492
Level 26 Mixist
A-zu-ra
 
 
 
post #75492 :: 2016.12.25 7:05pm :: edit 2016.12.25 7:07pm
Fourth song! This one's gonna be a doozy because this one, I'm gonna post TWO VERSIONS of the same song.

Helix Nebula / Anamanaguchi
(album ver.)
Helix Nebula / Anamanaguchi
(NSF only)
http://www.strawpoll.me/11956610
 
 

LOGIN or REGISTER to add your own comments!